Scroll Top
CounterClock with rose petals

The bloody 1989 Pelley family murders in Indiana are infamous, but has the whole story really been told?

spotify logo
Apple Podcast icon
Amazon Music icon
SiriusXM Icon
spotify logo
Apple Podcast icon
Amazon Music icon
SiriusXM Icon

CounterClock Season 3 is investigating the 1989 Pelley family murders in Indiana. Investigative journalist Delia D’Ambra sets out to re-examine the facts of the case that led to Jeff Pelley’s conviction and follow leads that connect the victims to unsolved crimes in South Florida.

This is Counterclock.

Season 3 Clock

Who’s Connected to the Case?

“Who did it?” is the question on everyone’s minds.

Moving counterclockwise, episode by episode, learn more about the people who knew the Pelleys and the people who were connected to the case.


Season 3 Trailer

Delia’s year-long investigation into the infamous Pelley family murders includes never-before-heard interviews from people closest to the victims and the initial police investigation. After reviewing more than 6,000 court documents, depositions, transcripts and photographs, Delia has traveled from Northern Indiana to South Florida following leads that connect unsolved crimes in the Sunshine State to the Pelley family.

This in-depth season is also closely examining the facts of the case that secured the 2006 conviction of Jeff Pelley.


women of the Pelley family

Episode 1: Establishing Base

Olive Branch United Brethren Church

Episode 2: Crime and Case

baby book on a bed

Episode 3: Evidence Race

view of parsonage through a window

Episode 4: Motive and Haste

Delia researching

Episode 5: Retrace

Jeff Pelley

Episode 6: No Clues to Waste

Delia at parsonage

Episode 7: Time and Place

Jeff Pelley mugshot

Episode 8: Switch and Bait

Episode 9: Years to Wait

Episode 10: Trial Phase Part 1

Episode 11: Trial Phase Part 2

Episode 12: Guilty Face

Episode 13: Check the Bank

Episode 14: Fines & Grace

Episode 15: Hogs & Snakes

Episode 16: Copy and Paste

Episode 17: Frauds and Fakes

Episode 18: Factually Based?

Episode 19: Name and Face

Episode 20: Picking Up Pace

Marshy woods in Florida

Bonus: Season 3 Q&A

media pass

Bonus: Evidentiary Hearing


Bonus: Jeff Pelley’s Status Hearing

If you have information on this case or you would like to contact Delia, email CounterClock@audiochuck.com.